Postmodernism,Psychiatry, and the Person:A Logical Inconsistency?
AbstractPostmodernist theoreticians have offered a powerful critique of psychiatry which they see as a modernist enterprise, born at the time of the European Enlightenment and currently operating under the aegis of evidence-based medicine. However, whilst their opposition to the view that there are objective truths about persons preserves the importance of the subjective, meaning making individual mind, collapsing the distinction between the subjective and the objective loses the reality of the personhood about which they are rightly concerned.
Bracken,P.,Thomas,P., 2001, March, Post-Psychiatry:a new direction for mental health, BMJ ;322:724-725
Bracken,P., 2002, Trauma: Culture, Meaning and Philosophy. Wiley Blackwell, Oxford
Heil,J., 2003, Philosophy of Mind: A Guide and Anthology, Heil, J., Oxford University Press, Oxford
Loewenthal,D., Snell,R., 2003 Post-Modernism for Therapists:A Critical Reader, Routledge Press, London
Evidence based medicine;in its place, 1995,Editorial, Lancet, ;346
Sackett,D.L.,Rosenberg, W.M.C., Muir Gray J.A.,Haynes,B.R.,Richardson,W.S., 1996, Evidence Based Medicine:what it is and what it isn’t,BMJ,312;71-72
Tallis, R., Aping Mankind: Neuromania, Darwinitis and the Misrepresentation of Humanity, Acumen Publishing, 2011
Weatherall,D.J., 1994, The Inhumanity of Medicine,BMJ;309;1671